Alice Eve for Captain America April 9, 2010 Will Alice Eve play Petty Carter? Alice Eve is in talks to play Captain America’s girlfriend Petty Carter in the upcoming movie. The 28-year-old star is on the shortlist of actresses to co-star in Marvel movie. Carter would join Chris Evans and Sebastian Shaw in the superhero movie. Eve will next be seen playing a nanny in the second Sex and the City film. Captain America, directed by Joe Johnston, is in cinemas in July 2011.