Will Alice Eve play Petty Carter? Alice Eve is in talks to play Captain America’s girlfriend Petty Carter in the upcoming movie. The 28-year-old star is on the shortlist of actresses to co-star in Marvel movie. Carter would join Chris Evans and Sebastian Shaw in the superhero movie. Eve will next be seen playing a nanny in the second Sex and the City film. Captain America, directed by Joe Johnston, is in cinemas in July 2011.